Section 40A(2) of Income Tax

Section 40A(2) of the

Income Tax Act authorizes an Assessing Officer to disallow deductions on expenses. An income tax deduction may be prohibited under Section 40A(2) on the grounds of the expenditure being undervalued or unreasonable to the fair market value of the corresponding goods, services or facilities.

Prohibiting Expenditure Incurred on Relatives

The following scenarios could lead to the disallowance of expenditure under this section:

The payment must be connected with an expenditure.
The payment must be remitted to specific persons.
The Assessing Officer finds the expenditure to be unreasonable and excessive with respect to the fair market value of the goods, services or facilities paid for, the benefits derived by or accruing to the assessee from the payment made or the legitimate business needs of the taxpayer’s business or profession.

These prohibitions are understood to be void in the face of specific transactions referred to in Section 92BA of the Income Tax Act if the transaction is at arm’s length price as defined in section 92F.

Specified Person

Taxpayers who are recording the specified expenditures in the books of accounts should understand that certain payments made to specified persons are disallowed according to the Act. The following persons are considered to be specified with reference to this section:

Individuals

Individuals may include relatives of individual such as a spouse, brother, sister, lineal ascendant or descendant of the individual like parents, grandparents, son, or daughter. Moreover, the provisions apply to a person in whose business or profession the individual or the relatives hold substantial interest.

Company/Firm/HUF

The provisions may be enacted on the directors of the

company, partners in a firm, members of HUF or Association of Persons (AOP), as well as to the family member, relative, partner or member of the director. Also, the provision applies to any person in whose business or profession, the director or a partner of the director, member or relative holds a substantial interest.

Other Taxpayers

Other taxpayers qualifying for this provision includes individuals who hold substantial interest in the business or profession operated by the payer. Further, the provision extends to a company, firm, AOP/HUF, and their relatives holding a substantial interest in the business or profession operated by the payer.

Explaining Substantial Interest

A person is considered to hold a substantial interest in a business or profession if the ‘specified person’ was the beneficial owner of shares in the previous year enjoying at-least 20% of the voting power in a given previous year. These shares should not have been entitled to a fixed rate of dividend, with or without a right to be involved in profits. In other cases, the person is deemed to be specified if the taxpayer is entitled to at least 20% of the profits of the business or profession in a given previous year. The relevant deductions on expenses under the Act shall be granted exclusively if the criterion of substantial interest stands satisfied.

Back to Learn

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about Section 40A(2) Income Tax Act: Disallowance Rules.

Section 40A(2) of the Income Tax Act authorizes the Assessing Officer to disallow deductions on expenses that are deemed excessive or unreasonable with respect to the fair market value of the goods, services, or facilities paid for, the benefits accruing to the taxpayer, or the legitimate business needs.

The expenditure can be disallowed if the payment is connected with an expenditure, the payment is made to specified persons, and the Assessing Officer finds the expenditure to be unreasonable or excessive in relation to the fair market value, benefits derived by the taxpayer, or legitimate business needs.

'Specified persons' include relatives of an individual taxpayer (spouse, siblings, lineal ascendants or descendants), persons in whose business the individual or relatives have a substantial interest, directors of a company or partners in a firm, their family members or relatives, and persons in whose business the directors, partners, or their relatives hold a substantial interest.

A person is considered to hold a substantial interest in a business or profession if they are the beneficial owner of at least 20% of the voting power or are entitled to at least 20% of the profits of the business or profession in a given previous year.

Yes, the prohibitions on expenditure disallowance under Section 40A(2) are void for specific transactions referred to in Section 92BA of the Income Tax Act if the transaction is at arm's length price as defined in section 92F.

It is crucial for taxpayers to understand Section 40A(2) because it can lead to the disallowance of certain expenditures, especially those made to specified persons, if they are deemed unreasonable or excessive by the Assessing Officer, potentially impacting their tax liability.

Taxpayers can ensure that their expenditures are not disallowed by maintaining proper documentation to justify the reasonableness of the expenses concerning the fair market value, benefits derived, and legitimate business needs, and by being cautious when making payments to specified persons.

Yes, Section 40A(2) is applicable to all types of taxpayers, including individuals, companies, firms, Hindu Undivided Families (HUFs), and Associations of Persons (AOPs), provided the conditions for disallowance of expenditure are met.

No, the Assessing Officer cannot arbitrarily disallow expenditure under Section 40A(2). They must provide a valid justification based on the criteria specified in the section, such as the expenditure being unreasonable or excessive in relation to the fair market value, benefits derived, or legitimate business needs.

The article does not specify any particular timeframe within which the Assessing Officer can invoke Section 40A(2) to disallow expenditure. However, it is generally expected that the Assessing Officer would examine the expenditure during the assessment proceedings for the relevant financial year.