Bollywood Actor Wins Tax Case: Key Lessons on Foreign Tax Credit (FTC)

If you earn income from outside India, it's crucial to report it correctly in your tax returns. Proper tax compliance can help you avoid legal disputes and ensure you benefit from Foreign Tax Credit (FTC) provisions. A recent case involving a Bollywood actor highlights how accurate tax reporting can protect taxpayers from reassessments by the Income Tax Department.

In this article, we’ll break down what happened, the legal findings, and key concepts taxpayers with foreign income should know.

Bollywood Actor’s Case: A Lesson in Tax Compliance

What Was the Issue?

Bollywood Actor earned money from his movie(2011), which was largely shot in the UK. Since he paid taxes in the UK, he claimed a Foreign Tax Credit (FTC) in India to avoid being taxed twice on the same income. His payment was handled through a UK-based company.

What Happened?

1. Original Tax Filing (2011-12)
• Bollywood Actor declared his income as Rs 83.42 crore in India.
• He claimed FTC for the taxes he had already paid in the UK.
2. Reassessment by the Tax Department
• The Income Tax Department reassessed his case years later and disputed his FTC claim, adjusting his taxable income to Rs 84.17 crore.
• They argued that the way his payment was structured caused a revenue loss for India.
• The problem? This reassessment happened after the legal four-year time limit, which is usually the deadline for reopening old tax cases.
3. Legal Battle & Final Verdict
• The case went to the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), which reviews tax disputes.
• ITAT ruled in favor of Bollywood Actor, saying that:
• The tax department had no new evidence to justify reopening the case.
• The reassessment was done too late and was not legally valid.

What This Means for Taxpayers?

• If you earn money abroad, you are allowed to claim Foreign Tax Credit for taxes already paid outside India.
• The tax department cannot reassess your income unfairly after the legal time limit expires.
• Proper documentation and filing taxes correctly can protect you from unnecessary disputes.

This ruling is a big win for taxpayers, reinforcing that tax laws must be followed fairly and assessments cannot be reopened without strong legal grounds.

Foreign Tax Credit 

Foreign Tax Credit (FTC) is a tax relief that prevents double taxation when you earn income in a foreign country and pay taxes there.

How It Works

If you are an Indian taxpayer and earn income from a foreign country, you may have to pay taxes in that country.

At the same time, India also taxes your global income.

To avoid paying tax twice on the same income, India allows you to claim a foreign tax credit—this means you can deduct the tax paid in the foreign country from your Indian tax liability.

FTC provisions are contained in tax treaties entered by India with other countries (in Bollywood actor's case, it was the India-UK tax treaty).

What You Need to Do If Earning Income in Foreign Countries?

If you are earning income from a foreign country, it is important to follow these steps to ensure compliance with Indian tax laws:

• Determine Your Residential Status: Your global income taxability in India depends on whether you qualify as a resident or non-resident.
• Report All Foreign Income: Declare all foreign earnings, including salary, business profits, dividends, and capital gains, in your tax return.
• Claim Foreign Tax Credit (FTC): If you have paid taxes abroad, use Form 67 to claim credit and avoid double taxation.
• Obtain a Tax Residency Certificate (TRC): This is necessary to claim benefits under DTAA agreements.
• Maintain Proper Documentation: Keep records of your income, foreign tax payments, and relevant agreements to support your claims.
• Convert Foreign Income Correctly: Use the applicable exchange rate from RBI to convert your earnings into INR for tax reporting.
• Consult a Tax Professional: International taxation can be complex, so seeking expert advice ensures compliance and maximised tax benefits. 

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Reporting Foreign Income

Not Declaring Foreign Income

Many taxpayers assume that if tax has already been paid in a foreign country, they don’t need to declare the income in India. However, all foreign income must be reported in Indian tax returns.

Missing the Deadline for FTC Claim

FTC claims require filing Form 67 before submitting the tax return. Delayed filing may lead to denial of tax credit benefits.

Failure to Maintain Proper Documentation

Taxpayers must keep records such as tax payment receipts, TRC, and income statements from foreign sources to substantiate their claims.

Incorrect Application of DTAA Benefits

Misinterpreting the provisions of DTAA can lead to errors in tax calculations, resulting in excess tax payments or penalties.

Not Converting Foreign Income Correctly

Income earned in foreign currency must be converted into INR using exchange rates provided by the RBI or authorized sources.

Also read: How much Foreign Income is Tax-free in India? 

Key Takeaways for Taxpayers

The Bollywood celebrity’s case serves as a valuable reminder that accurate tax reporting and proper documentation can protect taxpayers from legal challenges. This case highlights that taxpayers have the right to challenge unfair tax claims.

Ensuring proper tax compliance is crucial for taxpayers, especially those earning income from foreign sources.

Get Expert Tax Assistance with IndiaFilings!

Navigating international taxation and claiming Foreign Tax Credit can be complex. Ensure your tax compliance is in order and avoid unnecessary disputes by seeking professional guidance. IndiaFilings offers expert tax advisory services, helping individuals and businesses with tax filings, DTAA compliance, FTC claims and more.

Make sure you report your foreign income correctly and claim FTC the right way. Stay compliant, stay stress-free!

Need assistance? Consult a tax expert today!

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is Foreign Tax Credit (FTC)?

FTC allows Indian taxpayers to claim credit for taxes paid in a foreign country, so they don’t get taxed twice on the same income.

2. How does FTC work under Income Tax Rule 128?

• You can claim FTC in the year when the foreign income is taxed in India.
• If foreign tax is spread over multiple years, the credit is adjusted.
• FTC can’t be used for penalties or interest but can be claimed after resolving a foreign tax dispute.
• FTC is calculated separately for each income source and is limited to the lower of:
• Tax paid in the foreign country OR
• Tax payable in India on that income.
• You must submit proof of tax payments before the assessment year ends.

3. What is a Tax Residency Certificate (TRC) and why do I need it?

A TRC is a document from a foreign country confirming your tax residency there. It helps you claim benefits under tax treaties and avoid double taxation.

4. How do I know if I am a resident of India for tax purposes?

You are a resident if:

• You stayed in India for 182 days or more in a financial year OR
• You stayed in India for 60 days in the last financial year AND at least 365 days in the last four years.

If you qualify as a Resident and Ordinarily Resident (ROR), your global income is taxable in India. If not, only your Indian income is taxed.

5. How do I file Form 67 to claim Foreign Tax Credit (FTC)?

To claim FTC, you must file Form 67 online before submitting your Income Tax Return (ITR). Follow these steps:

• Log in to the Income Tax e-Filing portal.
• Go to e-File > Income Tax Forms > File Income Tax Forms.
• Select Form 67 and choose the relevant Assessment Year.
• Fill in the required details about your foreign income and taxes paid.
• Upload supporting documents like foreign tax payment proof and Tax Residency Certificate (TRC).
• Click Preview, verify the details, and e-Verify using OTP, DSC, or net banking.
• After submission, you will receive a transaction ID and acknowledgment number.

Form 67 must be filed before the due date of ITR filing to claim the tax credit. Missing the deadline can result in denial of FTC benefits.

About the Author